The Unraveling of a Creative Legacy: A Look into Steve Jobs’ Decision to Sell Pixar

USER

The story of Steve Jobs is one of a true visionary, a man who changed the world with his innovative ideas and creative genius. He was the co-founder of Apple, the company that revolutionized the personal computer industry, and later returned to the helm to lead the company to even greater heights. But amidst all his success, there was one decision that left many puzzled – why did Steve Jobs sell Pixar? This seemingly contradictory move by a man who was known for his relentless pursuit of perfection, begs the question – what drove him to let go of a company that he had nurtured and built from the ground up? In this article, we delve deep into the mind of a true icon, and unravel the reasons behind one of the most intriguing decisions of his life.

The Early Years: The Birth of Pixar

The Beginnings of a Revolutionary Animation Studio

In the late 1970s, a group of computer scientists and animators came together to form Pixar, a small animation studio with big dreams. Among them was Steve Jobs, the co-founder of Apple Inc., who saw the potential of computer-generated animation and believed that it could revolutionize the film industry.

Pixar’s early years were marked by innovation and experimentation. The team developed groundbreaking technology, such as the first fully computer-animated film, “Toy Story,” which was released in 1995. They also pioneered techniques such as rendering and texturing, which allowed for more realistic and detailed computer-generated images.

Despite their successes, Pixar faced numerous challenges in its early years. The company struggled to secure funding and faced skepticism from traditional animators who doubted the viability of computer-generated animation. However, Pixar’s team remained committed to their vision and continued to push the boundaries of what was possible.

One of the key factors that contributed to Pixar’s success was its collaborative culture. The company fostered an environment where artists and technologists worked together, sharing ideas and expertise to create groundbreaking films. This approach was in stark contrast to the traditional animation studios of the time, which were often hierarchical and siloed.

Overall, the beginnings of Pixar marked the start of a revolution in the animation industry. The company’s commitment to innovation, collaboration, and creativity laid the foundation for its future successes and cemented its place as a leader in the field of computer-generated animation.

The Partnership with Disney: A Marriage of Minds

The partnership between Pixar and Disney was a pivotal moment in the history of animation. The collaboration was the result of years of hard work and determination by Steve Jobs and his team at Pixar. Disney, which had long been a leader in the animation industry, saw the potential in Pixar’s groundbreaking technology and innovative storytelling.

The partnership between the two companies began in the late 1980s, when Steve Jobs and Disney chairman, Michael Eisner, first met. At the time, Pixar was still a small, struggling company, and Disney was looking for a way to revitalize its animation division. The two men hit it off immediately, and Pixar’s first feature film, “Toy Story,” was born.

The partnership between Pixar and Disney was a unique and highly successful collaboration. Each company brought its own strengths to the table. Disney provided the animation expertise and distribution network, while Pixar brought the technology and creative vision. The partnership was a marriage of minds, with each company pushing the other to reach new heights of creativity and innovation.

Under the partnership, Pixar and Disney released a string of successful films, including “Beauty and the Beast,” “Aladdin,” and “The Lion King.” These films were not only critical and commercial successes, but they also helped to redefine the animation industry. The partnership between Pixar and Disney set a new standard for animation, and the two companies continued to push the boundaries of what was possible in the field.

Despite the success of the partnership, tensions began to rise between Pixar and Disney in the late 1990s. The two companies had different visions for the future of animation, and they began to butt heads over creative control and financial issues. As the relationship between the two companies deteriorated, Steve Jobs began to explore other options for the future of Pixar.

The partnership between Pixar and Disney was a unique and highly successful collaboration that helped to reshape the animation industry. While the partnership ultimately came to an end, the legacy of the collaboration continues to inspire and influence the animation industry to this day.

The Turning Point: The Making of Toy Story

Key takeaway: Pixar’s success was due to its innovative technology, unique storytelling, and collaborative culture. The company’s commitment to pushing the boundaries of what was possible in animation, combined with its willingness to take risks and experiment with new techniques and approaches, helped to establish it as a leader in the field.

The Groundbreaking Film That Changed Animation Forever

In 1995, Pixar Animation Studios released its first feature-length film, “Toy Story,” which was a groundbreaking achievement in the world of animation. The film was the first-ever entirely computer-animated feature film, and it revolutionized the animation industry by demonstrating the potential of computer-generated imagery (CGI) in storytelling.

“Toy Story” was a collaboration between Pixar and Walt Disney Pictures, and it was directed by John Lasseter, who would later become the chief creative officer of Walt Disney Animation Studios. The film’s success was a testament to the hard work and innovation of Pixar’s team, who had spent years developing new technologies and techniques to create realistic and engaging characters and environments.

One of the key innovations that “Toy Story” introduced was the concept of “rendering,” which involved creating highly detailed and realistic images of characters and environments. This allowed Pixar’s animators to create characters that looked and moved like real people, which was a significant departure from the traditional animation techniques used in the past.

The film’s success was also due in part to its engaging storyline, which centered around the adventures of two toys, Woody and Buzz Lightyear, who come to life when their owner, Andy, is not around. The film’s blend of action, comedy, and heartfelt moments made it a hit with audiences of all ages, and it spawned two sequels, “Toy Story 2” and “Toy Story 3,” as well as a spin-off television series.

In addition to its critical and commercial success, “Toy Story” also earned several awards and accolades, including an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay. The film’s impact on the animation industry was significant, and it paved the way for other CGI-animated films, such as “The Lion King” and “Shrek,” which followed in its wake.

Overall, “Toy Story” was a groundbreaking film that changed the animation industry forever. Its success at the box office and its critical acclaim demonstrated the potential of CGI in storytelling, and it remains a beloved classic to this day.

The Critical and Commercial Success of Toy Story

The year 1995 marked a pivotal moment in the history of animation and the film industry as a whole, with the release of Toy Story, the first-ever feature-length computer-animated film. Directed by John Lasseter, Andrew Stanton, and Pete Docter, the film was produced by Pixar Animation Studios and Walt Disney Pictures, and it would go on to become a landmark in the animation world.

Critics and audiences alike were immediately drawn to the innovative storytelling and breathtaking visuals of Toy Story. The film’s blend of humor, heart, and groundbreaking animation set a new standard for the genre, making it clear that computer-animated films were here to stay.

Toy Story’s success was not limited to critical acclaim, as it also went on to become a box office hit. With a budget of $30 million, the film grossed over $361 million worldwide, making it the highest-grossing animated film of all time at the time of its release. The film’s financial success not only solidified Pixar’s place in the animation industry but also proved that computer-animated films could be just as successful, if not more so, than traditionally animated films.

In addition to its critical and commercial success, Toy Story also earned several awards and nominations, including two Academy Awards for Best Original Song and Best Original Score. The film’s impact on the animation industry was undeniable, and it paved the way for Pixar’s future successes, including classics like Finding Nemo, The Incredibles, and Up.

Overall, the critical and commercial success of Toy Story was a turning point for Pixar and the animation industry as a whole. It proved that computer-animated films could be just as successful as traditionally animated films and set a new standard for storytelling and visuals in the animation world.

The Rise of Pixar: A Decade of Dominance

The Continuing Evolution of Pixar’s Artistry and Innovation

During the early 2000s, Pixar continued to push the boundaries of animation and storytelling, delivering a string of critically acclaimed and commercially successful films. One of the key factors in Pixar’s ongoing success was its commitment to artistic growth and innovation. Here are some examples of how Pixar continued to evolve during this period:

Developing New Technologies

Pixar invested heavily in research and development, constantly seeking new ways to push the limits of computer animation. One notable example was the development of a new software system called “Renderman,” which allowed animators to create more realistic lighting and shading effects in their films. This technology was instrumental in achieving the stunning visual effects seen in films like “Finding Nemo” and “The Incredibles.”

Experimenting with New Storytelling Techniques

In addition to technological innovation, Pixar also sought to experiment with new storytelling techniques. For example, the film “Ratatouille” was notable for its use of a unique visual style, with the majority of the film taking place from the perspective of a rat who has a highly developed sense of taste and smell. This approach allowed the filmmakers to create a rich and immersive world that played with the audience’s senses in new and exciting ways.

Collaborating with New Directors

Pixar also began to expand its roster of directors, bringing in new talent to helm its films. For example, “Up” was directed by Pete Docter, who had previously worked as a storyboard artist on several Pixar films. Docter’s unique vision and sensibility helped to make “Up” one of Pixar’s most beloved films, earning it widespread critical acclaim and multiple awards.

Overall, Pixar’s commitment to artistic growth and innovation during the early 2000s helped to establish it as one of the most innovative and creative studios in the animation industry. Its willingness to take risks and experiment with new techniques and storytelling approaches helped to keep its films fresh and engaging, earning it a devoted fan base and critical acclaim.

The Expansion of Pixar’s Storytelling: From Finding Nemo to The Incredibles

Pixar’s Artistic Growth in Finding Nemo

Finding Nemo, released in 2003, marked a turning point in Pixar’s artistic growth. The film showcased a new level of depth and maturity in its storytelling, exploring themes of parenthood, loss, and self-discovery. Pixar’s commitment to creating a visually stunning underwater world was evident, with the movie’s vibrant colors and intricate details captivating audiences. The film’s emotional impact was heightened by its unique blend of humor and heart, making it a critical and commercial success.

Embracing Superheroes: The Incredibles

In 2004, Pixar took on a new challenge with The Incredibles, a superhero film that departed from the studio’s typical animated fare. The movie introduced a richly detailed world of superheroes and villains, complete with action-packed sequences and a strong emphasis on family dynamics. The Incredibles featured an impressive voice cast, including Craig T. Nelson, Holly Hunter, and Samuel L. Jackson, and the film’s stunning visuals showcased Pixar’s continued commitment to pushing the boundaries of animation.

The Incredibles also marked a departure from Pixar’s traditional coming-of-age narratives, instead focusing on the struggles of a middle-aged superhero, Mr. Incredible, as he tries to balance his family life and his heroic duties. This shift towards more complex themes and character development demonstrated Pixar’s growing ambition and willingness to take risks in their storytelling.

The critical and commercial success of both Finding Nemo and The Incredibles further solidified Pixar’s position as a creative force in the animation industry, setting the stage for the studio’s continued growth and innovation in the years to come.

The Decision to Sell Pixar: A Deep Dive into Steve Jobs’ Motivations

The Pressure to Deliver Continuously

As the co-founder and CEO of Apple, Steve Jobs was known for his relentless drive for innovation and his unwavering focus on delivering products that would disrupt the market. This pressure to continuously deliver groundbreaking products took a toll on Jobs, who was also the CEO of Pixar at the time.

The animation industry was notoriously difficult, with high risks and low returns. Despite this, Jobs was determined to make Pixar a success, pouring millions of dollars into the company and investing heavily in its technology and talent. However, the pressure to continuously deliver hits took a toll on Jobs, who felt that he was constantly living in the shadow of his own success.

In addition to the pressure to deliver, Jobs was also facing personal challenges. He had been diagnosed with cancer, and the future of Pixar was uncertain. It was in this context that Jobs made the decision to sell Pixar to Disney, a move that would ultimately secure the company’s future and cement its place as a leader in the animation industry.

Despite the pressure to deliver, Jobs never lost sight of his vision for Pixar. He believed in the power of animation to tell stories that would resonate with audiences, and he was determined to push the boundaries of what was possible with the medium. In the end, it was this unwavering commitment to creativity and innovation that would make Pixar the success it is today.

The Desire to Expand Beyond Animation

While Pixar’s success in the animation industry was undeniable, Steve Jobs had bigger dreams. He wanted to expand beyond animation and explore new frontiers in the world of technology. Jobs believed that Pixar’s unique approach to storytelling and innovative animation techniques could be applied to other areas, such as video games, virtual reality, and even medicine.

One of the key factors driving Jobs’ desire to expand beyond animation was his interest in gaming. He had always been a fan of video games and saw the potential for Pixar to create immersive gaming experiences that combined storytelling and animation. In 2006, Jobs even acquired a company called Next Level Graphics, which specialized in creating 3D graphics for video games.

Jobs also saw an opportunity for Pixar to enter the virtual reality market. He believed that Pixar’s expertise in animation could be used to create immersive virtual reality experiences that would revolutionize the way people interact with technology. In 2010, Jobs even demoed a Pixar-created virtual reality experience at the D8 conference, showcasing the potential for Pixar to expand beyond animation.

Finally, Jobs believed that Pixar’s unique approach to storytelling could be applied to other areas, such as medicine. He saw an opportunity for Pixar to use its animation techniques to create medical simulations that could help doctors and patients better understand complex medical procedures. In 2009, Pixar partnered with the Mayo Clinic to create a series of medical animations that would help doctors explain medical procedures to their patients.

Overall, Steve Jobs’ desire to expand beyond animation was driven by his interest in gaming, virtual reality, and medicine. He believed that Pixar’s unique approach to storytelling and innovative animation techniques could be applied to these areas, and he was determined to explore new frontiers in the world of technology.

The Role of Disney in the Decision to Sell

  • The Impact of Disney’s Animation Dominance
    • The Walt Disney Company’s long-standing dominance in the animation industry
    • Pixar’s struggle to compete with Disney’s well-established brands and characters
    • The potential for Pixar to broaden its appeal by joining forces with Disney
  • The Allure of Disney’s Distribution Network
    • Disney’s vast distribution network and marketing capabilities
    • Pixar’s limited reach compared to Disney’s global presence
    • The opportunity for Pixar to expand its audience through Disney’s resources
  • The Influence of Disney’s Creative Culture
    • Disney’s reputation for fostering creativity and innovation
    • Pixar’s desire to collaborate with Disney’s talented animators and storytellers
    • The potential for Pixar to learn from Disney’s established techniques and methodologies
  • The Promise of Disney’s Financial Stability
    • Disney’s strong financial position and stability
    • Pixar’s dependence on box office success for revenue
    • The appeal of a more secure financial future through a merger with Disney
  • The Role of Michael Eisner in the Negotiations
    • Michael Eisner’s desire to expand Disney’s animation portfolio
    • Eisner’s willingness to pay a premium for Pixar’s talent and library
    • The influence of Eisner’s personal relationship with Steve Jobs on the negotiations
  • The Pressure to Settle the Acquisition
    • Pixar’s declining stock price and the need for a resolution
    • Steve Jobs’ reluctance to accept a lower offer from Disney
    • The eventual agreement on a $7.4 billion buyout deal

The Aftermath: Pixar’s Transition to Disney and the Legacy That Remains

The Merger That Created a Media Giant

The merger between Pixar and Disney in 2006 was a landmark event in the world of animation and media. It brought together two of the most innovative and creative companies in the industry, and the result was a media giant that dominated the box office and captivated audiences around the world.

One of the key factors that led to the success of the merger was the shared vision of the two companies. Both Pixar and Disney were committed to creating high-quality, family-friendly entertainment that would appeal to audiences of all ages. This shared vision allowed the two companies to work together seamlessly, resulting in some of the most successful films of the past decade.

Another important factor was the leadership of Steve Jobs and Bob Iger, the CEOs of Pixar and Disney respectively. Both men were visionaries who understood the importance of innovation and creativity in the industry. They were able to navigate the complexities of the merger and create a new company culture that was both collaborative and innovative.

The merger also had a significant impact on the animation industry as a whole. It sparked a new era of innovation and creativity, as other studios looked to emulate the success of Pixar and Disney. It also led to a wave of consolidation in the industry, as other companies sought to compete with the new media giant.

In the end, the merger between Pixar and Disney was a turning point for both companies and the industry as a whole. It created a new media giant that has dominated the box office and captured the hearts and minds of audiences around the world. While the legacy of Steve Jobs and Pixar remains strong, the merger with Disney has allowed the company to reach new heights of success and creativity.

The Preservation of Pixar’s Autonomy and Creative Spirit

Although Pixar was now a subsidiary of Disney, the company’s management and employees were determined to preserve the autonomy and creative spirit that had been the cornerstone of its success. This dedication to maintaining the essence of Pixar was crucial in ensuring the continued success of the studio and the legacy it had established.

The Importance of Autonomy in the Creative Process

Pixar’s autonomy was a critical factor in the development of its unique style and storytelling. The company’s independence allowed it to take risks and pursue creative ideas without interference from external forces. This autonomy fostered a culture of innovation and encouraged artists and filmmakers to push boundaries and experiment with new techniques and concepts.

The Commitment to Maintaining Creative Freedom

After the acquisition by Disney, Pixar’s management made a concerted effort to maintain the company’s autonomy and creative freedom. This commitment was evident in the way Pixar continued to operate as a separate entity within Disney, with its own distinct culture and management structure. The company’s leadership understood that preserving this autonomy was essential for maintaining the creative legacy that Pixar had established.

The Role of Disney in Supporting Pixar’s Autonomy

While Pixar was determined to preserve its autonomy, it was also clear that the acquisition by Disney had the potential to provide significant resources and support. Disney’s vast experience in the entertainment industry and its financial strength could potentially benefit Pixar, allowing the company to expand its operations and explore new creative avenues.

The Balance Between Autonomy and Support

In order to preserve Pixar’s autonomy and creative spirit, the company’s management sought to strike a balance between maintaining its independence and utilizing the resources and support provided by Disney. This balance was essential in ensuring that Pixar could continue to innovate and push the boundaries of animation while benefiting from the resources and expertise of its new parent company.

The Continued Pursuit of Innovation and Excellence

Despite the acquisition by Disney, Pixar remained committed to its core values of innovation, creativity, and excellence. The company’s dedication to these principles allowed it to continue producing groundbreaking films that captured the hearts and imaginations of audiences worldwide. The preservation of Pixar’s autonomy and creative spirit played a crucial role in this ongoing success and the enduring legacy of the studio.

The Impact on the Animation Industry and Popular Culture

  • Revolutionizing Animation Techniques:
    • The integration of computer-generated imagery (CGI) in animation
    • Development of new animation software and tools
    • Advancements in character rigging and facial expression techniques
  • Emphasis on Storytelling and Emotional Connection:
    • Pixar’s unique approach to storytelling and character development
    • The creation of memorable and relatable characters
    • Fostering an emotional connection between audiences and animated films
  • Inspiring a New Generation of Animators and Filmmakers:
    • Pixar’s influence on the animation industry, attracting talent and resources
    • Encouraging innovation and creativity in storytelling and visual effects
    • Paving the way for new animation studios and projects
  • Transforming Popular Culture:
    • Pixar’s films becoming part of the cultural fabric
    • Iconic characters and quotes entering everyday language
    • Inspiring merchandise, theme park attractions, and spin-off franchises
  • The Continuation of Pixar’s Legacy:
    • Pixar’s impact on Disney’s animation renaissance
    • The growth and expansion of the animation industry as a whole
    • The enduring influence of Pixar’s creative vision and innovation on future generations of filmmakers and audiences alike

The Enduring Legacy of Steve Jobs and Pixar

The Transformation of the Film Industry

Steve Jobs and Pixar’s decision to sell to Disney marked a significant turning point in the film industry. Pixar’s groundbreaking animation technology and innovative storytelling techniques had already revolutionized the world of animation, but the sale to Disney allowed for even greater opportunities for growth and expansion.

  • The acquisition of Pixar by Disney in 2006 created a powerhouse in the animation industry, with Disney now possessing the creative talents of both Pixar and its sister studio, Marvel.
  • The combined forces of Disney and Pixar allowed for a broader range of storytelling opportunities, as well as the ability to reach a wider audience.
  • The success of Pixar’s films had already proven that audiences were hungry for high-quality, computer-animated films, and the merger with Disney only further fueled this demand.
  • The sale of Pixar to Disney also opened up new avenues for collaboration and cross-promotion, with Disney characters appearing in Pixar films and vice versa.
  • This move also marked a significant shift in the business model for animation studios, with more and more studios following suit and adopting computer-animated techniques in their productions.
  • Overall, the sale of Pixar to Disney represented a major turning point in the film industry, marking the rise of computer-animated films as a dominant force and paving the way for new opportunities and collaborations in the years to come.

The Continuing Inspiration for Creatives Everywhere

Steve Jobs’ impact on the world of technology and creativity is immeasurable. His work at Pixar, a studio that he co-founded, revolutionized the animation industry and left an indelible mark on popular culture. Even after his death in 2011, Jobs’ legacy continues to inspire and influence creatives everywhere.

One of the reasons why Jobs’ legacy endures is because of the way he approached creativity. He believed that creativity was not just for artists and designers, but for businesspeople and engineers as well. He saw creativity as a way to solve problems and innovate, and he encouraged people to think differently and challenge the status quo.

This philosophy is evident in the way Pixar approaches animation. The studio is known for its innovative storytelling techniques, groundbreaking technology, and unique visual style. Pixar’s films are not just entertaining; they are also thought-provoking and emotionally resonant. They inspire viewers to see the world in new ways and to appreciate the beauty and complexity of the world around them.

Pixar’s influence extends beyond the world of animation and into other areas of popular culture. The studio’s films have inspired countless imitators and homages, and its characters have become iconic figures in the cultural landscape. Even people who have never seen a Pixar film are familiar with characters like Woody, Buzz Lightyear, and Nemo.

But Pixar’s influence is not just cultural. It is also economic. The studio’s films have grossed billions of dollars at the box office, and its success has inspired other companies to invest in animation and other forms of digital media. Pixar’s innovations in technology and storytelling have also inspired other industries, from healthcare to education, to think differently about how they approach their work.

For all these reasons, Steve Jobs and Pixar continue to be a source of inspiration for creatives everywhere. Their legacy reminds us that creativity is not just a matter of talent or luck, but also a matter of hard work, perseverance, and a willingness to take risks. It reminds us that creativity is not just an individual pursuit, but a collective one, and that we can all contribute to the creative legacy of our time.

The Lasting Impression of Pixar’s Revolutionary Vision

In the world of animation, Pixar has left an indelible mark. Its innovative storytelling and revolutionary technology have captivated audiences for decades, with films like “Toy Story,” “Finding Nemo,” and “The Incredibles” becoming beloved classics. Pixar’s groundbreaking techniques, such as the use of computer-generated imagery (CGI) and the incorporation of sophisticated software, have not only transformed the animation industry but have also expanded the creative possibilities for filmmakers.

Pixar’s approach to storytelling has also been instrumental in its success. The company has consistently produced films that resonate with audiences of all ages, combining humor, heart, and action in a way that few other studios have been able to replicate. From the unlikely friendship between a cowboy toy and a space ranger in “Toy Story” to the complex relationship between a clownfish and his son in “Finding Nemo,” Pixar’s stories have consistently explored themes of family, friendship, and identity in a way that is both entertaining and emotionally impactful.

The influence of Pixar’s work extends beyond the world of animation and into popular culture. The studio’s characters and catchphrases have become ubiquitous, with franchises like “Toy Story” and “The Incredibles” inspiring countless merchandise, spin-offs, and even stage shows. Pixar’s impact on the broader cultural landscape cannot be overstated, with its films often referenced and parodied in other media.

Ultimately, Pixar’s lasting impression can be attributed to its commitment to innovation, creativity, and storytelling. By pushing the boundaries of what was possible in animation, Pixar has not only changed the way films are made but has also inspired a new generation of filmmakers and artists. The legacy of Pixar’s revolutionary vision is one that will continue to be felt for years to come.

FAQs

1. Why did Steve Jobs sell Pixar?

Steve Jobs sold Pixar to Disney in 2006 due to a number of reasons. One of the main reasons was that he wanted to focus on Apple, which was going through a difficult period at the time. He had also become frustrated with the slow pace of progress at Pixar and believed that Disney’s resources and distribution network would allow Pixar to reach a wider audience. Additionally, Jobs saw the sale as an opportunity to finally realize his dream of building a theme park, which he had long wanted to do.

2. What was the impact of the sale on Pixar?

The sale of Pixar to Disney had a significant impact on the company. While some worried that the acquisition would lead to a loss of creative independence, Pixar has continued to produce critically acclaimed films under the Disney umbrella. The sale also brought a greater level of financial stability to Pixar, allowing it to invest in new technologies and creative projects. Additionally, the sale allowed Pixar’s employees to access Disney’s vast resources and distribution network, further expanding the company’s reach.

3. What was Steve Jobs’ role at Pixar after the sale?

After the sale of Pixar to Disney, Steve Jobs remained as a consultant to the company. He was heavily involved in the early stages of the creative process, providing feedback and guidance to Pixar’s filmmakers. However, as time went on, Jobs’ involvement with Pixar lessened as he focused more on his work at Apple. Despite this, he remained a strong supporter of Pixar and its creative vision.

4. What were the terms of the sale?

The terms of the sale between Pixar and Disney were not disclosed to the public. However, it is known that Steve Jobs received a significant portion of the $7.4 billion sale as part of the deal. Additionally, Pixar’s management team, including Jobs, were given seats on Disney’s board of directors. The sale also included a provision that allowed Pixar to maintain its unique culture and creative independence, a key concern for Jobs during the negotiations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *